A Colbert Christmas: The Greatest Gift of All: A Review
The Christmas season is upon us and our culture is once again under attack with Christmas albums and Christmas specials and Christmas themed food items and movies with an implausible Father Christmas calendars with pictures of dogs wearing Santa-hats. Yet it’s only once in a lifetime that one of these myriads of seasonal offerings manages to be so inspiring and so indicative of its time that becomes a holiday staple: It’s A Wonderful Life. A Charlie Brown Christmas. How The Grinch Stole Christmas. A Christmas Story. The Star Wars Christmas Special.
A Colbert Christmas? Sadly, no. Now, don’t get me wrong. Mr. Colbert has once again brought the funny. His special is a pitch-perfect parody of specials of a bygone era (so bygone, in fact, that I’m way too young to have seen any in their original form: everything I know about them comes from parody and YouTube). It combines this parody with Mr. Colbert’s own character’s (Stephen Colbert) unique quirks and running jokes in amusing ways: Stephen can’t get to his studio to do his Christmas special because a bear has trapped him in his mountain cabin. Comedy legend John Stewart stops by to sing a delightful song about Hanukkah. Country music legend Toby Keith stops by to sing about the war on Christmas. English Singer-songwriter legend Elvis Costello stops by to say things like “Father Christmas” and “Happy Christmas” (oh those wacky Brits).
Much laughter and mirth is had by all, especially us as we watched the DVD. Unfortunately, I just can’t imagine re-watching it. It doesn’t have the necessary humor-juice to hold up to repeatable viewings. And, as a parody, it doesn’t have the sincerity needed to become a true holiday classic in the vein of Charlie Brown. Of course, that’s true of all of Colbert’s current stuff, I guess. By its very nature, it’s highly topical and funny at the time; but a couple of months later, what’s the point? I think most people will find the same true of this DVD. Far from being the greatest gift of all, it’s more of an endorsement for Netflix.